(Why am I thinking of Heckle and Jeckle? Or maybe Spy vs. Spy?)Happy Memorial Day!
English sailors, you say?
(Maybe a cousin to those English sailors from before, there) So, two variations are arising: one is the age-old vodka vs. gin battle. The other, and more significant, one is whether or not there's a sweetener. Rose's Lime Juice (which we saw in the first recipe, too) is a proprietary syrup you've probably seen in grocery stores. There may or may not be actual lime juice in it, but it's certainly sweet.
In this earlier version, we find sugar -- also throwing in the curve ball of carbonated water. A little bit of sparkle!
Here's another recipe, this one from a 1957 edition of Old Mr. Boston's:
Their recipe is still the same 2:1:1 ration they used above. Except, of course, they call for triple sec (which is okay, actually).
Obviously, their recipe contemplates a 1:1:1 ratio -- unless, they note, you want a "strong brandy accent," in which case, use a 3:1:1 ratio. Also, curacao (instead of Cointreau or triple sec) is going to make for a lot drier drink.
With smiles and everyone in high spirits, it's obvious that this has been a successful evening.